问题原文
原帖链接 · Hannah Vernon · CC BY-SA 3.0
If disks have 512-byte physical sectors, and you have 10 disks using RAID 50 with a 1MB stripe-size how does that work at the disk level?
Correct me if I'm wrong, but conceptually, there would be 2 spans each consisting of a RAID-5 array of 5 disks, one mirrored to the other. Therefore, a "stripe" would consist of 4x256KB chunks of data, plus a single 256KB of parity data per stripes? or does a "stripe" include the parity?
What if you consider a 12-disk RAID 10 array? There would be 6 mirrored pairs of disks, with striping over those mirrors. So, for a 1MB stripe size, the stripe would be divided by 6, for 174,762.666 bytes per-disk, which works out to 341.333 physical sectors per stripe. Is that really 342 physical sectors per stripe?
For those who wonder why I'm asking; I am attempting to determine the most efficient number of disks relative to the type of RAID, with the best stripe size.
Also, I have seen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nested_RAID_levels prior to asking this question. In fact, I've done a ton of work looking for low-level design details on a vast multitude of SCSI / SAS / RAID / SAN vendor sites, and have not seen anything that talks about the actual on-disk format of stripes. Stripes are only talked about at a highly conceptual level, which is fine, but doesn't really answer the question.
社区高分解答
原帖链接 · Massimo · CC BY-SA 3.0
You will find all relevant details here.
Basically, all your assumptions are correct: RAID 50 is a striping (RAID 0) of RAID 5 arrays, while RAID 10 is a striping of RAID 1 arrays.
How this is physically implemented, however, depends strongly on the disk controller; sometimes, additional space is used for internal informations, so you can't know exactly how, when and where every single byte is used, unless you ask the controller vendor.
About the stripe size: this is almost never relevant, unless you are into heavy performance tuning; in this case, it can have an impact, but it depends (again) on the controller and disks you are using, and also on the OS, the filesystem and the actual I/O load.
As a rule of thumb, it's good practice to have the stripe size of the RAID array match the cluster size of the filesystem with which the volume residing on that array will be formatted; and that size should be chosen depending on the I/O load the volume is expected to handle (many small files or lots of big files?); but this is only a general suggestion; and, again, lots of other parameters can influence I/O performance.
Also, keep in mind that you could have multiple volumes on the same RAID array (even more so if you are working with a SAN instead of local storage), each of them potentially using a different cluster size and handling a different I/O load.
If you really want to fine-tune your storage to such a level, not only you will need complete control of each and every element from the physical disks to the actual application storing data on them, but you will also have to analyze them carefully and customize a lot of parameters, of which stripe size is only one of many.
A simple case study: Exchange writes database transaction logs as 1-MB files, sequentially; they are mostly written and rarely read under normal operation; they can take up some space, but never too much if regular backups are performed, because they get truncated (i.e. the oldest ones are deleted) everytime a full backup of the database is completed.
The best possible approach for storing this kind of data would be to use a RAID 1 array of two disks, with a stripe size of 1 MB, battery-backed-up write cache, a single volume formatted with the NTFS filesystem and 1-MB cluster size; oh, and of course you'll have to store only the transaction logs for a single database on this volume; if you have more DBs, you will need to use different volumes and disk arrays, or you'll lose all benefits of sequential I/O. (BTW, the actual database data must go to a whole different place, and not only for performance but mostly for data safety; have a look at the Exchange documentation if you want more details; but the basic points are, they have completely different I/O patterns and you absolutely don't want to lose both the database and the transaction logs at the same time.)
As you see, this kind of assessment is very strongly dependent on the expected I/O load, and wouldn't be adequate for anything else than storing Exchange transaction logs in a very specific setup; it will probably hinder any other workload.
Storage fine-tuning is an art, and requires lot of analysis and experience to get it correct.
摘自公开归档,保留原文语言,版式经整理,外部媒体与邮箱地址已移除。
